Does God Care More About Sex Than Marriage?

Does God Care More About Sex Than Marriage?
Posted on: April 30th, 2012 by Leslie Vernick

Good morning friends,

Thank you for all your comments and notes encouraging me to continue writing this blog. I want to serve you and meet your needs and so I appreciate the feedback. I was in Dallas, TX all weekend speaking at the Wonderful Counselor Conference, so what I thought I’d do is share with you a blog I recently wrote for this organization titled, Does God Care more about Sex than Marriage?

I know many of you struggle with the issue, and, although I wrote this blog for counselors, I trust many of you will find it helpful.

You may even want to print it out or forward it to your counselor or pastor.

Does God Care More About Sex than Marriage?

by Leslie Vernick LCSW

As a biblical counselor, how would you respond to a client who asks…

“I’ve been married for 25 years to an emotionally and verbally abusive man. He regularly curses at me, calls me degrading sexual names, refuses to have a normal conversation with me, and mocks me in front of our children. He will not see a counselor nor talk with our pastor.

I don’t want a divorce, but I’m tired of trying to make this better. I feel angry and bitter toward him for the way he treats me, yet he still expects me to be loving and affectionate with him, especially in bed. I can’t do it. What does God expect me to do?”

This is one of those difficult questions to answer thoughtfully and biblically, and I fear in this short blog I won’t be able to adequately tackle this issue. But I’m asked this type of question so frequently; I want us to talk about it.

One of the most standard answers women hear from biblical counselors on this topic is that God’s word is clear. She may not withhold herself sexually from her husband, citing 1 Corinthians 7.

But what are we saying to a hurting woman by this counsel? Are we saying that her husband’s sexual needs (or desires) are more important to God than her emotional well-being? Are we telling her that God calls her to meet her husband’s sexual needs regardless of the damage he’s done to her spirit or their relationship? Are we telling her that God says she never has a choice? She is to be available sexually no matter what?

That is a horrible picture of God, and it is not who He is. When we paint that picture of God, we are telling a woman that God values a man’s sexual needs and desires more than a woman’s need for love and safety, and this is not the truth. God cares equally for both individuals in a marriage and for the relationship itself.

In answering this woman’s question, we must look at the whole counsel of God with respect to marriage and not take one passage about sex in marriage as the sole biblical answer to her dilemma.

What does God say about marriage and the way a husband should treat his wife?

Marriage was not designed by God as a legitimate way for a man to get sex, but rather a loving partnership between a man and a woman. Tim Keller in his recent book on marriage writes, “The Christian teaching [on marriage] does not offer a choice between fulfillment and sacrifice but rather mutual fulfillment through mutual sacrifice.*”

The important word here is mutual. When one person in a marriage is not sacrificing or loving or caring, a biblical marriage is not happening. The scriptures teach, “Husbands love your wives as Christ loved the church” (Ephesians 5:25) and are instructed not be harsh with them (Colossians 3:19).

Granted, no husband is perfect, but when there is repeated emotional and verbal harshness and cruelty with no evidence of repentance, remorse, personal responsibility or change, the marriage relationship as God designed, is clearly broken.

The question we must ask ourselves as biblical counselors is what is the wife’s responsibility in these situations? Is she to prop up the broken marriage and try to act as if all is still well? Or, does that approach enable her husband to continue to be self-deceived believing he can act selfishly and sinfully towards her with no consequences?

What does God say to the wife and what should her biblical response be to the way her husband is treating her?

God’s word clearly tells us not to retaliate when we are sinned against. Instead we are to overcome evil with good (Romans 12:21). As counselors, one part of helping this wife overcome her husband’s evil with good is to help her forgive her husband and deal with her anger and bitterness toward him.

But here is where we must be exceptionally wise. When we help her forgive and let go of her bitterness (which are good goals), if he continues to treat her as he always has, it would be realistic for her to continue to be wary of him and unable to feel wifely affection or sexual attraction toward him.

Next, the bible commands believers to love, including our enemies. But what does biblical love look like toward an abusive husband? Biblical love isn’t necessarily feelings of affection, warmth, or sexual attraction, but actions that are directed toward another person’s good or long term best interests. We can help this woman overcome evil with good when we help her biblically love her husband.

Therefore, is it in her husband’s good and long term best interests to be available to him so that his sexual needs are met? If the answer is yes, then keep in mind this still does not address their marital problem, it is only a solution to his sexual frustration.

Often when counseling a woman in this kind of dilemma, I find she has lost sight of her God designated role as her husband’s help mate. As his partner, she can love him by helping him become the man God designed him to be. As his wife, she is not a second class citizen with no power or say. That kind of wife was biblically called a concubine and clearly not God’s intent for marriage.

In cases where repeated abuse is present, it is always in her husband’s best interest for him to repent of his selfishness, pride, and submit to God (James 4:7). It would also be in his best interest and in the best interest of their marriage for him to learn to control his tongue (James 1:19; James 3:10-12) and become more thoughtful and considerate of his wife’s feelings (Philippians 2:3-4).

When we tell a woman that no matter how her husband treats her God says she must have sex with him, what we’re saying is that God cares more about the fact that her husband is sexually hungry than the fact that her husband is hurting her and their marriage relationship. And, that’s not biblical.

We need a new paradigm. Let’s help this wife learn to speak up to her husband lovingly but firmly and say,

“No, I can’t have sex with you in a godly way because of the way you treat me. I can’t feel affectionate toward you when I feel afraid. When you curse at me, scream at me, and call me horrible names it breaks my heart. I am God’s image bearer, not an object to be used for sex and then discarded when you’re finished. With God’s help, I choose to forgive you, but I can’t reconcile with you in a loving relationship until you begin to see the damage you’re doing to me and to our marriage and change.”

Words of truth spoken in love and humility are the potent medicine her husband needs to wake up to the fact that he can’t expect the perks of a good marriage without changing his ways and putting in some work. The scriptures are full of examples of God’s law of consequences. What you sow, you reap (Galatians 6:7). If her husband wants a good marriage and not just a concubine, he will need to stop sowing thorns and thistles into his wife’s heart.

Overcoming evil with good empowers this woman to take constructive action that may lead to the restoration of their marital relationship. That would be good for him, good for her and good for their family.


Leslie’s book and blog can be found at

I cannot recommended this book enough!  The Emotionally Destructive  Marriage..It’s full of Godly wisdom that we all need!  Buy it today!!



6 thoughts on “Does God Care More About Sex Than Marriage?

  1. “No, I can’t have sex with you in a godly way because of the way you treat me. I can’t feel affectionate toward you when I feel afraid. When you curse at me, scream at me, and call me horrible names it breaks my heart. I am God’s image bearer, not an object to be used for sex and then discarded when you’re finished. With God’s help, I choose to forgive you, but I can’t reconcile with you in a loving relationship until you begin to see the damage you’re doing to me and to our marriage and change.”

    Wow, I’ve actually done something right for a change by telling my husband ( MANY TIMES) these words. Lonely, despite that my husband has heard these words from me and our therapist ( years ago), he simply flips the denial switch when they are spoken to him. He has absolutely no desire to be accountable or proactive in saving his marriage by fostering trust, happiness, security or anything else that is good for us.

    • Exodus….so do you still have sex with him? Do you still sleep in the same room? I’m curious how things are, knowing you’ve told him this!
      PA Man has never been verbally abusive, thank goodness!!
      That’s why when he called my son a “weirdo” I was sooo furious!

      How do you deal with it? Is it worth it staying with him? How do your kids deal with it all?
      Sorry if it’s too many questions :/ I’m sorry that he calls you horrible names….that’s disgusting!!
      Is there NO one that will help you?? Family? Church??
      Can you tape record him calling you names…and take it to someone who would help you, once they know the truth??

  2. Lonely, I haven’t had sex with him in gosh, many many years and have absolutely no desire to. My husband doesn’t call me names or hit me. He’s 100 percent PA…the smiling devil.

    I don’t share a bed with my husband anymore and I don’t engage with him on any level except business matters. There is no connection between us at all so anytime I try to converse with him about anything, it’s like talking to no one.

    No, there is no one to help me. I’m not sure how anyone could help me unless they are willing to hire me.

    No, I don’t have any kids with him thank G-d. That was another thing I did right in my life. You have no idea how thankful I am that I don’t have children to worry about. Then again, if I had kids, maybe I would have been less tolerant and left here years ago. PA man would have been a horribly immature and negligent father.

    • So why do you stay? Because of the business? Or is it easier to just ignore him and live your life?
      I’ll admit…I have a comfortable life, and the thought of leaving and doing it on my own is scary!
      And I do have kids, and as long as they seem happy, I try to be content…my problem has been sex…I don’t like it or want it…there is no emotional connection and I feel used….I hate being a fake, since I feel I’m a fake in the rest of my life!

      • I stay because of money. I can’t support myself without a job and my husband can’t support two homes, two of everything. I don’t necessarily need to live with my husband to help run our business but he’s so dangerous when it comes to money and making business decisions that I feel a bit more at ease seeing him at the end of the day. What I mean is that it provides an opportunity for me to read his body language and to ask him questions relative to work.

        It sounds like your husband could afford to pay you child support and provide a decent home for you and the kids so why don’t you leave? Just because kids seem happy doesn’t mean they are. If you’re not happy, then the kids aren’t going to be happy. I know you already know that. It doesn’t seem right to stay there just because you have more luxuries than you would if you didn’t. In actuality, that would mean that you are using him! Is that why you stay? It may be your PA way of ‘ making him pay’? Just something to think about.

        I can’t imagine sex with my husband. Just thought of it makes me sick. If I were in love with someone, I would love to have sex but otherwise, like you, I just can’t stand being used to satisfy a man’s physical need.

        One of the reasons that I won’t do any social functions with my husband is because of the need to pretend that we are ‘ ok’ in order to maintain a pleasant experience. I’m not a liar and never have been until I met my husband and began covering up for him, etc.. I won’t do it anymore and haven’t in a long time. The last time I saw his parents with him, I told it just like it was and actually said, ” I’m not taking anymore of your SH&* ” right in front of his father! hahaha His father walked past me and said, ‘ Now, now’ They are steeped in as much denial as they can be and because they claim to be Christians, it annoys me even more because denial is the spineless act of selfishly perpetuating a lie which G-d does not approve of. This is also why G-d does not approve of us staying in these self defeating and abusive relationships. We are not living in truth as long as we stay. G-d knows that I’ve tried to find a way out of here but I haven’t tried hard enough and truthfully, I haven’t devoted enough thought to asking G-d for help because I feel so hopeless. I know He can work miracles in our lives because He’s worked many in my own. Maybe I just feel like I don’t deserve His help this time?

  3. Exodus….yes, I stay because of the money, amongst other reasons… I do think we could swing it if we were to separate…But I really don’t want to go there If we don’t have to!
    I am happy most of the time, believe it or not…Yes, when PA Man is being a jerk, it drives me up the wall…but he travels a lot which is nice….he was gone for four days last week, and is leaving again tomorrow 😀
    I don’t walk on eggshells, and my guts are not in a knot…been there, done that after the affair came put…decided I didn’t want to live like that anymore!! I WAS miserable then!!
    Because he travels a lot I have lots of freedom to do what I want and
    he doesn’t really care what I do, he’s very laid back….as long as I don’t expect to much from him, he’s good!
    And that suits me fine!

    And yes, I think there’s a bit of the “I’ve EARNED this nice lifestyle!” in my thinking, LOL!!!
    As most young couples, we struggled financially over the years, being in the military, etc… but now PA Man is in a decent position with his company where we can afford nice vaca’s, home, etc..
    As long as I don’t bring up emotional “stuff” we are good, He doesn’t yell, curse, get verbally abusive….the “perfect” passive agressive man, If there ever was one!

    Another reason I never looked at divorce was because of the misguided teaching about divorce that is prevalent in churches today!
    Thats why Leslie Vernicks book was so amazing to me….she laid it out so simply…God hates the way PA Man acts, He hates that PA Man is in bondage to this sin and He hates that PA Man doesn’t love me the way he’s commanded to, and He doesn’t want me enabling him in this sinful lifestyle!
    But now I know the truth…and for now I’m going to try to “stay well”….when my youngest reaches maturity….thenwe will see how things are.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s